The Center for Equine Health and the Bernard and Gloria Salick Equine
Viral Disease Laboratory took a proactive step in the fight against
emerging viral diseases on May 16, 2000. Dr. Gregory Ferraro, CEH
Director, and Dr. James MacLachlan, Director of the Bernard and
Gloria Salick Equine Viral Disease Laboratory, hosted a meeting
on West Nile fever with regulatory officials
from both the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and
the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA), horse
industry representatives from various breeds and disciplines, and
scientists with expertise in equine virology. The informational
seminar provided a forum to discuss the implications of West Nile
fever on the California equine industry and to help prepare for
a possible outbreak this summer. Last August through October, the
West Nile virus caused illness and death in horses, humans and birds
in New York. The virus was also identified in wild birds in Connecticut
and New Jersey. Prior to this outbreak, the West Nile virus had
never been documented in the Western Hemisphere. Veterinary pathologists
at the Bronx Zoo noted a large number of crows dying near the zoo
and examined the birds. Shortly after, people in northern Queens,
just across the East River from the zoo, were reported with encephalitis-like
infections and some of the zoo birds suddenly died. Twenty five
horses were infected in one location on Long Island and eight of
those animals died. The culprit was eventually identified as the
West Nile virus, an encephalitis virus.
West Nile virus was originally discovered in 1937 in Uganda. Subsequently,
it has been recognized throughout Africa, the Middle East and Eastern
Europe. This virus was not known to exist in the Western Hemisphere
until the New York outbreak last summer. Considering the historical
record for how viruses spread once they are established in a geographical
area, North Americans should expect the disease to become an endemic
problem for them as well. This winter, scientists identified the
virus in mosquitoes and in a dead red tailed hawk in New York which
proves that the virus has over-wintered in New York. However, given
the migratory patterns of birds within the Western Hemisphere, the
virus could re-appear anywhere in the United States this summer.
West Nile virus is categorized within the Japanese encephalitis
group of viruses. This group includes many viruses already endemic
in California such as western equine encephalomyelitis (WEE), Venezuelan
equine encephalomyelitis (VEE) and St. Louis encephalitis. West
Nile virus is very closely related to the St. Louis virus; both
of them are designated scientifically as flaviviruses. The virus'
natural hosts are birds that migrate between the northern and southern
hemispheres, and the virus is transmitted between birds by mosquitoes.
Horses, humans and other susceptible animals are considered "accidental
" or "dead-end" hosts that become infected after being bitten by
infected mosquitoes. While the virus causes illness in these accidental
hosts, most infected birds do not become ill, thereby making them
excellent carriers of the disease.
The disease causes inflammation of the central nervous system,
but the clinical symptoms for West Nile fever in the horse
and in man often are not diagnostic. They include typical
encephalitic symptoms such as disorientation, dementia and
coma. In the horse, the disease can present as a weakness
or ataxia of the hind limbs. The viremiaand fever that occur
following initial infection in the horse often precede the
neurological symptoms by several weeks; therefore, the disease
can be confusing and difficult to diagnose in the horse. There
is no specific treatment for West Nile fever other than lessening
the severity of central nervous system disturbance. Currently,
there is no vaccine for West Nile fever and routine vaccination
against western and eastern equine encephalomyelitis does
not confer protection against West Nile fever. |
Dr. Bernard Salick discusses the horse owners'
concerns regarding West Nile fever.
|
The disease causes inflammation of the central nervous system, but
the clinical symptoms for West Nile fever in the horse and in man
often are not diagnostic. They include typical encephalitic symptoms
such as disorientation, dementia and coma. In the horse, the disease
can present as a weakness or ataxia of the hind limbs. The viremia
and fever that occur following initial infection in the horse often
precede the neurological symptoms by several weeks; therefore, the
disease can be confusing and difficult to diagnose in the horse.
There is no specific treatment for West Nile fever other than lessening
the severity of central nervous system disturbance. Currently, there
is no vaccine for West Nile fever and routine vaccination against
western and eastern equine encephalomyelitis does not confer protection
against West Nile fever.
The meeting's speakers and attendees were carefully selected to
represent various sides of this issue so that pertinent questions
and concerns could be addressed. Following an introduction by Dr.
Ferraro, Dr. Bennie Osburn, the Dean of the UC Davis School of Veterinary
Medicine, discussed the veterinary school's role in addressing emerging
viral diseases. Dr. Fred Murphy, former Dean of the UC Davis School
of Veterinary Medicine and former Director for the Center for Infectious
Diseases, Centers for Disease Control, discussed the global status
of emerging infectious diseases.
The USDA's agricultural research arm was represented by Dr. Geoff
Letchworth, the Research Leader for the Arthropod Borne Animal Disease
Research Laboratory in Wyoming. He explained the disease and discussed
its current research status. Dr. Dana Nelson of the USDA's Animal
and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) for California and Nevada,
and Dr. Richard Breitmeyer of the CDFA, outlined the regulatory
response that could be expected should any viral encephalitis outbreak
occur within California.
|
Speakers at the West Nile
fever meeting conducting a panel discussion. (left to right)
Dr. Richard Breitmeyer-CDFA, Dr. Dana Nelson-USDA, Dr. John
Edman-UC Davis Center for Vector Borne Disease, Dr. Geoff
Letchworth-USDA, Dr. Michele Jay-State of CA Public Health
Vet., Dr. Sharon Hietala-CA Animal Health and Food Safety
Lab., Dr. Bernard Salick-Sandstone Farm and Ms. Amy Mann-American
Horse Council.
|
California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory (CAHFS)
spokesperson Dr. Sharon Hietala discussed the strategies for dealing
with emerging equine viruses in California, including the sentinel
chicken program for the early detection of arboviruses (those
transmitted by mosquitoes). This disease warning system has been
used for many years within California to indicate the presence
of dangerous infectious disease agents. Officials maintain flocks
of chickens and test them every other week to detect antibodies
to various diseases to which the chickens have been naturally
exposed. Dr. Hietala also discussed the many diagnostic services
available to California horsemen through the CAHFS service.
The public health perspective was represented by Dr. John Edman,
Director of the UC Davis Center for Vector Borne Disease, and
Dr. Michele Jay, Public Health Veterinarian for the State of California.
They discussed the importance of identifying an outbreak of the
virus early on so that proper control measures could be adopted.
Early detection is accomplished by increasing surveillance through
the sentinel chicken flocks and by collecting mosquitoes and testing
for a much larger range of viruses to include the flaviviruses.
Any sample that tests positive for St. Louis encephalitis needs
to be further tested for West Nile virus.
Ms. Amy Mann, the Director of Health and Regulatory Affairs for
the American Horse Council, represented the horse industry's point
of view. She clearly stated horse owner's concerns regarding regulatory
issues such as possible restrictions on the international movement
of horses, the need for interaction and coordination between regulatory
agencies, and the proper dissemination of accurate information
to the public. She also decried the lack of federal funding to
the USDA for research and disease control of diseases affecting
the equine industry. Ms. Mann clearly made the point that if the
West Nile virus did not have the potential to infect humans, there
would be no national governmental interest in this disease. She
urged all horsemen to lobby their local Congressional representatives
on this issue.
Helen Scott-Orr, the Executive Director of Research, Advisory
and Education for the New South Wales Department of Agriculture
in Australia, explained concerns regarding the international movement
of horses to and from areas where West Nile fever was identified.
Considering the large number of people and horses that are expected
to attend the Olympic Games this summer in Australia, it is reasonable
to expect regulators to institute any and all measures necessary
to protect public health and safety. Animals from any areas experiencing
a contagious disease outbreak will most likely be denied travel
to Australia.
Dr. Bernard Salick of Sandstone Farm, represented the show horse
owner's point of view. He raises Holsteiners that compete at World
Class levels in jumping and dressage. His farm in Thousand Oaks,
California has been designated as this year's quarantine area
for the US horses competing in the Olympic Games. He discussed
the monetary investment owners have in top quality competitive
horses and how infectious diseases affect breeding, sales and
showing of these animals. He shared his passion for infectious
disease research and stated that because there is no worldwide
standard for equine disease control, UC Davis and the Bernard
and Gloria Salick Equine Viral Disease Laboratory have the power
to set a standard, starting with West Nile fever.
| Dr. James MacLachlan, Director
of the Bernard and Gloria Salick Equine Viral Disease Laboratory,
discussed the current status of equine virology research.
He stated his goal was not to create hysteria regarding West
Nile fever, but instead, to put a group together to address
the important issues. He said the equine viral disease laboratory
would hold the high ground scientifically and offer a research
resource to those investigating the disease. The laboratory
will also train the next generation of veterinary scientists
to be prepared for emerging equine viral diseases. He concluded
by moderating a panel discussion for questions and answers. |
Dr. James MacLachlan, Director of the Bernard
and Gloria Salick Equine Viral Disease Laboratory.
|
The first step in dealing with this issue is to identify what we
know -- to differentiate between fact and fiction -- which was the
purpose of this meeting. Once the facts are laid out, the next step
is to identify what we need to know. The million dollar question
is can West Nile fever be transmitted from horse to horse or from
horse to other animals and humans? If it can be transmitted, then
regulatory agencies throughout the world are justified in establishing
quarantine procedures. If it turns out the horse is a dead-end host
(can not transmit the disease to others), then quarantine procedures
are not necessary and researchers can concentrate on diagnostics
and treatment.
Dr. Letchworth is currently investigating this question in Colorado
and holds the key to handling this disease. This study is on the
fast track and he plans to have more information by the end of this
year. He is working in a biosecurity level 3 laboratory, one of
very few that are certified to conduct this type of research --
this laboratory is able to safely contain live infected mosquitoes
for research. UC Davis does not have this kind of research laboratory
for equine viruses; however, the campus is currently discussing
developing a biosecurity level 3 laboratory for horses because of
the increase in emerging viruses. The Bernard and Gloria Salick
Equine Viral Disease Laboratory was developed to combat these diseases
through research and is collaborating with scientists in South Africa
who have experience with West Nile fever and have banked infected
sera (blood) available for research.
Do we want to develop a vaccine? Scientists could easily and quickly
develop a vaccine for West Nile fever, but there are some things
to consider. With some diseases, immunoenhancement occurs where
the first exposure to the virus causes a mild immune response, but
the second or third exposure results in a much more severe reaction.
A vaccine could also cause this complication and until the disease
is further investigated, immunoenhancement remains a risk with vaccination.
In addition, once a horse is vaccinated, would scientists be able
to differentiate between actual disease and mere exposure/previous
vaccination? If quarantine regulations are instituted, a vaccinated
horse may test positive for the disease and would not be allowed
to travel in non-infected areas.
What should we do right now? Increase surveillance and research!
Dr. Fred Murphy stated "We have to be prepared for a diverse set
of risks for the future. A strong research base is the key for action
-- without research, we have no keys to move forward." The sentinel
chicken flocks will provide an early warning of a West Nile fever
outbreak and Dr. Letchworth's research in the biosecurity level
3 laboratory will shed some light on how this disease spreads.
What should we do to prepare for an outbreak this summer? Eliminate
standing water to prevent mosquito breeding areas and use mosquito
repellent sprays on your horses. Limit outdoor exposure during periods
of peak mosquito activity, especially after dusk. Watch for any
large bird die offs in your area and report it to local CDFA officials
(see inset for contacts). Also watch for signs of encephalitic disease
in your horses such as depression, dementia, head pressing, and
weakness or ataxia in the hind limbs. The disease can easily be
mistaken for equine protozoal myelitis (EPM), herpes virus or rabies
so consult your local and state veterinarians.
Dr. Gregory Ferraro, Center for Equine Health
Director, hosted the West Nile fever meeting.
|
Although we won't
know if West Nile fever will be a problem again until the
summer, it is prudent to plan for a possible outbreak. Now
that the virus has been introduced to the United States, it's
likely that it is here to stay and sooner or later, it will
emerge. Other countries will most likely play it safe and
set quarantine regulations which will affect the international
movement of horses. The Center for Equine Health and the Bernard
and Gloria Salick Equine Viral Disease Laboratory are working
together with researchers, regulatory officials and practicing
veterinarians to educate and inform the horse-owning public
so that if West Nile fever rears its ugly head, we will have
a plan of action to fight it. |
One major new disease a year emerges in humans. Dr. Ferraro stated,
"Today's disease is West Nile fever; tomorrow, it could be something
else," and the CEH and the Bernard and Gloria Salick Equine Viral
Disease Laboratory plan to be prepared to meet the challenge.
|
|
|
To report outbreak information or for consultation,
contact:
California Department of Food and Agriculture;
Animal Health and Food Safety Services;
Animal Health Branch
Sacramento Headquarters
Dr. Ken Thomazin
Phone: (916) 654-1447
FAX: (916) 653-2215
Redding District
Dr. Charles Palmer
Phone: (530) 225-2140
FAX: (530) 225-2240
Modesto District
Dr. David Willoughby
Phone: (209) 491-9350
FAX: (209) 491-9353
Fresno District
Dr. J. Kendell Harding
Phone: (559) 237-1843
FAX: (559) 237-4337
Ontario District
Dr. Herbert Little
Phone: (909) 947-4462
FAX: (909) 923-5128
|
|
|